Sunday, October 30, 2016

Essay Tests in Music Education

Most music education testing is performance based or objective multiple choice tests.  However, when studying music as an undergraduate student, my music history tests were often essay tests.  I think essay tests can be effective in the music discipline because they require students to analyze, interpret, and synthesize the knowledge they've accumulated throughout the course.  Effective essay tests call for the transfer of the knowledge that one has learned through the communication of his or her thoughts and ideas about the topic. By regurgitating information within the framework of one's own thoughts and ideas, the student can demonstrate mastery of content at a deeper level than simply memorizing facts for a multiple choice test.  The end of the year final in my high school music classes incorporates short answer portions in addition to the multiple choice questions so that I can get a glimpse into my students minds and see if they have really mastered the musical concepts we've covered in class.

Saturday, October 22, 2016

Performance Assessment Rubrics

Figure 1
Recently my high school instrumental students completed a performance assessment that judged their current skill level at playing our Christmas concert music.  They complete these assessments once every three to four weeks and receive feedback on a variety of criteria.  The rubric expands as we cover more and more aspects of performance technique throughout the year. Figure 1 is the first rubric in the series and evaluates students on their ability to play the correct notes and rhythms with appropriate stylistic expressivity.  They are also evaluated on their contribution to the ensemble.  Students perform this assessment in small groups of four to six members so that I can hear and provide accurate feedback for individual students.  This performance assessment not only provides feedback for students, but it also guides my instruction immediate following the test as I respond to the concepts and techniques that need further improvement (Shermis & Di Vesta, 2011).  Moreover, students are able to better understand  the elements of a quality performance and strive for excellence if they have a rubric that identifies these criteria.  I know for my students, rubrics have given them the ability to see beyond the score or grade, and to focus on the real-life application of performance techniques within the music discipline.

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Formative & Summative Assessment in Practice

Formative assessment is a natural part of the daily music rehearsal process, while summative assessment is usually the end of quarter concert.  However, after taking classes this summer I decided to incorporate more summative assessment and see if that helped students take more ownership of their learning.  One example of this is a recent lesson plan in which choir students learned about blending and tone quality.  They completed a formative pre-assessment where they were asked to verbally brainstorm words and ideas associated with blending and tone quality.  Then I recorded the students singing one of our a cappella pieces before launching into the lesson. Formative assessment continued as I listened to students blend and tonal quality during the lesson activities.  I then recorded the students singing the song again at the end of the lesson. Then the students listened to both recordings and made observations and answered targeted questions using the concepts and vocabulary they learned during the lesson. This summative assessment allowed students to see the progress they made and analyze their own performance.  I found that the students enjoyed this assessment and they were excited about what they had accomplished in their performance technique.

Sunday, October 9, 2016

Thoughts on Statewide Standarized Testing

Mention statewide standardized testing among a group of educators and you'll immediately hear groans and grumbles.  Teachers are caught between a rock and a hard place in when it comes to standardized tests.  We know assessment is necessary to ensure students are learning and progressing, but we are skeptical about one test's ability to effectively track student understanding.  We look at our classes and see the individual abilities, knowledge, skills, and needs of thirty different kids and we think...how are we going to ensure each of these students does well on this one important test?  Anxiety builds throughout the year as we realize certain students are falling behind in reading, math, or science.  We reteach, scaffold, and tutor these students in order to help them succeed.  We do everything in our power to ensure all our students are prepared and then, when testing begins, we pray they perform to the best of their ability.  And then we wait to face judgement day.  Will our students' scores indicate we are effective teachers or will this be the year our administrators call us in to talk about an "improvement plan"? Frankly, this is a terrible way to measure teacher effectiveness and it causes a serious amount of anxiety for educators.  There is never going to be a standardized test that provides adequate (and comprehensive) evidence of student progress or teacher effectiveness because every student is unique.  So cue the groans and grumbles, because until we come up with a better system, educators and students will continue to be at the mercy of standardized tests.

Wednesday, August 24, 2016

General Inquiry Reflection

4.1 Demonstrating Knowledge of Content and Pedagogy. In order to demonstrate mastery of this program standard, a teacher must plan and implement lessons using a variety of pedagogical practices.  Figure 1 illustrates the relationships between planning, instruction, and assessment as it relates to student learning.
Figure 1: Cycle of Effective Teaching (EdTPA)

During this course, I learned how to create clear and measurable learning targets, scaffold and differentiate lessons, communicate high expectations, plan informal and formal assessments, ask open ended questions, and incorporate student voice and academic language in my lesson planning.  This new knowledge will help me better plan, instruct and assess my students this year.  

Before beginning this course, I was unsure how to differentiate lesson activities and provide learning support for the exceptional learners within my classes.  Now I am excited to go back through my school curriculum and design lessons that provide opportunities for students with a variety of abilities and styles.  I plan to utilize questioning, reflection, cooperative activities, multiple assessment formats, nonlinguistic assignments, and student-led discussion to keep my students engaged and active in their learning (Marzano, 2007).

*  Marzano, R. J. 2007. The Art and Science of Teaching. Alexandria, Virginia: ASCD

Wednesday, August 17, 2016

Intro to Teaching Reflection

As stated in Internship Performance Criteria 8.2, teachers grow and develop professionally when they participate in a collaborative educational community where feedback is given by colleagues to improve instruction and advance knowledge of teaching practices and methods.  Through collaborative learning in this course, I gained an understanding of how culturally relevant teaching practices can positively impact students in my classroom.

The purpose of culturally relevant teaching is to enhance learning by connecting academic concepts to students’ cultural knowledge, prior experiences and performance styles (see Figure 1). 
Figure 1
For every human being, previous experiences and cultural contexts determine the lens through which he or she learns.  It is vital that educators validate students’ identities and backgrounds by incorporating curriculum that includes their life experiences in their learning. As students and teachers become more familiar with the cultures represented in their community, they learn to value diversity, self-assess their own biases, and understand dynamics of difference within their school (Cross, 1989).

As I’ve participated in the course over the last eight weeks, one of my students has been on my mind. This particular high school student’s incredible work ethic is admired by all of the teachers at my school and he regularly receives good grades.  However, last year he started falling behind on assignments, often fell asleep in class, and missed several days of school. Eventually I pulled him aside to express my concern and ask what was causing these changes.  He explained that his father, a Mexican immigrant, had broken his ankle and was unable to work.  So he was working two jobs in order to help the family pay their bills, taking care of his father and younger siblings while his mother worked, and desperately trying to stay on top of the ever-mounting pile of homework so he could get good enough grades to go to college.  I was shocked! No wonder he had trouble learning at school. 

If teachers don’t understand the cultural factors and experiences that affect their students’ learning at school, they cannot provide the support and resources these students need to succeed.  This year, I hope to develop better knowledge of my students’ previous cultural experiences, plan curriculum that is relatable to students’ everyday lives, and facilitate discussion that opens students’ eyes to the diverse perspectives present in our classroom (Kozleski, 2010).   By accomplishing these goals, I can provide learning opportunities that help my students develop cultural competence and connect what they know to what they learn.

* Cross, T.L. (1989). Towards A Culturally Competent System of Care. Retrieved from http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED330171
* Kozleski, E.B. (2010). Culturally Responsive Teaching Matters!. Retrieved from http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED520957



Saturday, July 23, 2016

Piaget's Cognitive Development

Piaget’s Four Stage Theory is one of the leading theories on cognitive development. He identifies sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational, and formal operational as the four stages of psychological development.  During the sensorimotor stage, infants use their five senses to learn about the world through examination and experimentation, eventually developing object permanence.  Responses in this stage are based solely on their immediate circumstances due to their inability to categorize objects and situations.  Years 2 to 7 are considered the preoperational stage.  Pressley and McCormick (2007) explain that during this stage children develop symbolic schemes “that allow them to represent objects or events by language, mental images, and gestures” (p. 62).  Deferred imitation, symbolic play, egocentrism, and conservation also begin during this phase of development. Primary school students fall into the concrete operational stage as they have the ability to understand facts but still find it difficult to comprehend abstract ideas and concepts.  Cognitive categorization and organization develop during these years allowing students to understand relationships between items and place them in order according to specific parameters. Finally, the formal operational stage begins in early adolescence as socialization, problem solving,  and abstract and forward thinking develop. Students in this phase are capable of in-depth discussion, multi-factored problem solving, and forming hypotheses.

The implications of these stages greatly influence curriculum, lesson planning, and instruction in the classroom.  Because students develop at various paces, educators must diagnose their students’ current developments stages in order to identify appropriate class content and instructional methods for their students.  Sensitivity to students’ limitations must be coupled with a commitment to equilibration as the teacher helps their students move from one cognitive stage to the next.  Constructivist approaches best aid this advancement by providing experiential learning in the form of guided discovery, modeling, and collaboration.  It is through these methods that teachers can provide an engaging and challenging classroom experience that caters to each of their students’ developmental needs.